Mungo Ponton (1801–1880): The Edinburgh Lawyer Who Found Light in Dichromate
Contents
In May 1839, months after photography was announced to the world, an Edinburgh lawyer told the Society of Arts for Scotland that he had found a cheap way to make photographic paper without silver. Mungo Ponton had noticed that paper treated with a dichromate salt darkened in light. He did not patent the idea, and he did not fully understand why it worked. Yet his observation became the basis of carbon printing, gum printing, photogravure and the photomechanical methods that put photographs into books, magazines and newspapers. This card tests the claim that an amateur's note founded a whole branch of printing.
TL;DR
- established Mungo Ponton (1801–1880) was an Edinburgh Writer to the Signet who became solicitor and then secretary of the National Bank of Scotland. He was a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh from 1834.
- established On 29 May 1839 he described to the Society of Arts for Scotland a photographic paper made with potassium dichromate (then called bichromate of potash), which needed no silver. He published it in the Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal and did not patent it.
- established Later researchers, including Talbot, found that the key reaction was between the dichromate and organic matter such as gelatine, which hardens in light. This became the basis of carbon printing, gum bichromate, photogravure and many photomechanical processes.
- shared The photographic historian Michael Gray describes Ponton's 1839 announcement as the first public account of the principle, while noting that he did not realise his salt was combining with the size in the paper.
Key Facts
- Born
- 20 November 1801, Balgreen, Edinburgh
- Died
- 3 August 1880, Clifton, Bristol; buried in Edinburgh
- Profession
- Writer to the Signet (1825); solicitor (1838) and secretary (1840) of the National Bank of Scotland
- Discovery
- Light sensitivity of dichromate-treated paper, announced 29 May 1839
- Published
- Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal, 1839
- Honours
- Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh (1834); silver medals of the Society of Arts for Scotland (1838 and 1845)
- Legacy
- Dichromated-colloid processes: carbon print, gum bichromate, photogravure, collotype and photolithography
A Note on Claims and Evidence
established claims rest on Ponton's 1839 paper, the records of the Society of Arts for Scotland, the National Bank of Scotland's records now held by NatWest Group, and histories of photographic processes. shared claims involve interpretation of priority and influence. traditional claims are repeated but not documented.
The weak points are these. Others had noticed the light sensitivity of chromium salts before 1839 in a purely chemical context; the Austrian historian Josef Maria Eder credited the German chemist Gustav Suckow with observing it in 1832. Ponton's contribution was to propose it as a photographic process. One account says he used sodium dichromate; his paper refers to the potassium salt.
Timeline
Born at Balgreen, Edinburgh.
Becomes a Writer to the Signet.
Elected Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh.
Becomes solicitor to the National Bank of Scotland; Society of Arts silver medal for work on the electric telegraph.
Announces dichromate photographic paper to the Society of Arts for Scotland.
Becomes secretary of the National Bank.
Talbot repeats Ponton's experiment while working on printing plates.
Society of Arts silver medal for recording temperature variations on photographic paper; publishes a faster calotype variant.
Resigns from the bank because of ill health.
Joseph Swan patents the carbon process, built on dichromated gelatine.
Dies at Clifton, Bristol.
Details
A banker with a laboratory
established Ponton trained as a lawyer and became a Writer to the Signet in 1825. In 1838 he joined the National Bank of Scotland as its salaried solicitor, and in 1840 he also became its secretary. Science was his passion. He was elected to the Royal Society of Edinburgh in 1834, and in 1838 the Society of Arts for Scotland gave him a silver medal for his work on the electric telegraph.
The 1839 discovery
established Photography burst on the world in January 1839, with the announcements of Daguerre's and Talbot's processes. Both relied on expensive silver salts. Ponton, experimenting with Talbot's method, found that paper soaked in a dichromate solution turned from yellow to brown where light struck it, and that the unexposed salt could be washed away to fix the image. On 29 May 1839 he presented this to the Society of Arts for Scotland as a cheap alternative to silver-based photographic paper, and he published the method that year. He chose not to patent it.
shared Ponton's images were not permanent in the way later processes would be, and he did not realise why his paper worked. The photographic historian Michael Gray explains that the dichromate was reacting with the gelatine size in the paper. When that was understood, the discovery became immensely useful: gelatine, gum or albumen mixed with a dichromate hardens in proportion to the light it receives, while unexposed parts wash away. Gray adds, quoting J. M. Barrie, that the discovery confirmed "there are few more impressive sights in the world than a Scotsman on the make".
From Ponton's paper to the printing press
established Talbot repeated Ponton's experiment in 1842 and used dichromated gelatine in his photographic engraving patents of 1852 and 1858. Alphonse Poitevin in France and others developed carbon printing, collotype and photolithography from it, and Joseph Swan's carbon tissue of 1864 made permanent carbon prints practical. Karel Klíč's photogravure of 1879, which the Glasgow firm of T & R Annan brought to Britain, also used a dichromated gelatine resist. For a century, dichromated colloids underpinned the reproduction of photographs in print, and related light-hardening resists are still used in printing and electronics.
Later life
established Ill health from the mid-1840s forced Ponton to take leave from the bank, and he resigned in 1846. He moved to Clifton, near Bristol, for its milder climate, and continued to write on science and religion. He died there in 1880 and was buried in Edinburgh.
Did You Know?
- Ponton announced his silver-free photographic paper in May 1839, only months after photography itself was made public.
- He never patented the discovery, while others built patented processes on it.
- The same principle that Ponton noticed lies behind photogravure, the process James Craig Annan made famous as an art.
- Ponton was a banker by profession: secretary of the National Bank of Scotland.
FAQ
1What did Mungo Ponton discover?
That paper treated with a dichromate salt is sensitive to light, giving a cheap, silver-free way to make photographic images.
2Why does it matter?
Once it was understood that dichromate hardens gelatine and similar substances in light, the principle became the basis of carbon prints, photogravure and most methods of printing photographs in ink.
3Was he the first to notice that chromium salts react to light?
No. Chemists had observed it earlier. Ponton was the first to propose and publish it as a photographic process.
Sources and Further Reading
Primary/Institutional
- Mungo Ponton, "Notice of a cheap and simple method of preparing paper for photographic drawing, in which the use of any salt of silver is dispensed with", Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 27 (1839).
- NatWest Group Heritage Hub, "Mungo Ponton".
Scholarly/Critical
- Michael Gray, "Carbon Printing: Black as a Colour", in Julie Lawson, Ray McKenzie and A. D. Morrison-Low (eds), Photography 1900: The Edinburgh Symposium (National Museums of Scotland and National Galleries of Scotland, 1994).
- A. D. Morrison-Low, "Photography in Edinburgh in 1839: the Royal Scottish Society of Arts, Andrew Fyfe and Mungo Ponton", Scottish Photography Bulletin 2 (1990) — further reading.
General
- Mungo Ponton, Wikipedia — used to check dates.
Caveats: Myths and Disputed Claims
- Myth: Ponton invented carbon printing and photogravure. He noticed the light sensitivity that later workers such as Talbot, Poitevin, Swan and Klíč built on, and he did not fully understand why his paper worked.
- Myth: Ponton was the first to see chromium salts react to light. Others noticed it earlier in a purely chemical context. Josef Maria Eder credited the German chemist Gustav Suckow with observing it in 1832. Ponton's contribution was to propose it as a photographic process.
- Disputed: which dichromate salt he used. One account says sodium dichromate, but his paper refers to the potassium salt, bichromate of potash.
Finished reading? Try the Fact Machine: three reels, one surprising Scottish connection →
A Great Scots story