Methodology

How We Score

The Scottish Impact Index (SI Score), explained.

What the SI Score is

Every card carries an SI Score: six categories, each scored from 1 to 10, for a total out of 60. Each collection uses its own six category names, because what counts as impact differs between, say, an invention and a moment in history.

Scores are editorial judgements made against a published rubric. They compare cards within a collection, not between collections — a History card and an Inventions card are scored on different scales.

The six categories in each collection

Inventions

  1. Global Impact
  2. Longevity
  3. Economic / Material Impact
  4. Originality / Distinctiveness
  5. Legacy (Built Upon)
  6. Recognition
See the Inventions rankings →

Discoveries

  1. Global Impact
  2. Longevity
  3. Economic / Material Impact
  4. Originality / Distinctiveness
  5. Legacy (Built Upon)
  6. Recognition
See the Discoveries rankings →

Institutions

  1. Societal Impact
  2. Institutional Longevity
  3. Material Contribution
  4. Institutional Distinctiveness
  5. Systemic Legacy
  6. Recognition
See the Institutions rankings →

History

  1. National Impact
  2. Enduring Significance
  3. Material Consequences
  4. Historical Distinctiveness
  5. Legacy for Scotland
  6. Recognition
See the History rankings →

Ideas

  1. Intellectual Influence
  2. Enduring Relevance
  3. Practical Consequences
  4. Originality of Thought
  5. Intellectual Legacy
  6. Recognition
See the Ideas rankings →

Reviews and revisions

Scores are reviewed as articles are revised. When new research changes how we understand a card, its score can change too. Newly added cards show "SI Score coming soon" until their scores have been reviewed.